At first, she posted anonymously at Cecilia's blog. Then she took on the name of "Hope."
She is married, with children. She is deeply closeted, and in love with her best friend. She is an evangelical Christian, who sees no way out of her marriage or the straitjacket of her life.
We are not so different, Hope and I.
Her posts probably resonated so deeply with me because it was not that long ago that I was where she is. I am straight and a very progressive Christian---but I, too, could see no way out of a marriage that was destroying my soul, and death seemed preferable to remaining where I was.
(For the record, evangelicals are not the only ones who take their commitments to both marriage and God seriously...)
I worry about Hope these days. She started a blog, where she began to talk about her attraction to her best friend and her sadness over her life. Despite the moniker she assumed, she felt hopeLESS and trapped--emotions I know far too well.
What worries me is that she deleted her blog. I think I know why. She was getting too much affirmation from people who are NOT closeted--and probably from people like me, who have lost all hope, only to find it in unexpected places.
It can be disconcerting to find people of faith and goodwill telling you that you do not have to be miserable. That being miserable is not necessarily God's will for your life...
I think about the living, breathing Hope a lot. And I worry about her---about her safety, about her happiness, about her dreams.
To find hope---REAL hope---can be the most frightening experience in life. The "small H" hope is a dangerous thing, I think. The flare of hope causes us to catch our breath and ask difficult questions. It causes us to dream dreams and wish for a different future than the one laid out before us by the expectations of others.
Joseph Campbell, the noted mythologist, once said "“If you can see your path laid out in front of you step by step, you know it's not your path."
That is the truth I came to know about my own life...and I suspect that Hope saw the possibilities of another life and was scared to death by the prospect.
I understand, but I wish it were otherwise.
I doubt Hope reads my blog, but, if she did, these are the things I would tell her...
- On a lonely road, I heard God say "You do not have to live this life. There are other options." I'm not really very good at listening, as a rule, but I'm glad I did that time...I suspect that God would like to say the same to you.
- I believe that Jesus meant it when he said "I am come that you might have life, and have it more abundantly."
- Children adapt---and a healthy and sane mother is a great gift to any child.
Mostly, I've got no issue with that. As a Christian (albeit an imperfect and struggling one), I think we are all called to do this. As I noted in my post below, I think Jesus had a rather feminine way of looking at life---and he barely hesitated to make the ultimate sacrifice for an ungrateful world.
This is exactly what almost any mother would do.
But I also believe that we serve and honor God best when we are true to ourselves. I know that my relationship with God is on a whole different level since I stopped embracing misery as my lot in life. Misery actually became my shield against God. It became my shield against feeling and love. I cannot believe that honored God--the God of love, mercy, and grace--at all.
Hope, if you are out there, please let us know you are still hanging in. Where there is life...there is Hope. You are not alone...and joy can come in the morning.
I am praying for you, my friend.
Doxy's note: It was late when I wrote this post, so that is my only excuse for forgetting to add one of my favorite poems...
Hope is the thing with feathers
That perches in the soul,
And sings the tune--without the words,
And never stops at all,
And sweetest in the gale is heard;
And sore must be the storm
That could abash the little bird
That kept so many warm.
And on the strangest sea;
Yet, never, in extremity,
It asked a crumb of me.
---Emily Dickinson


30 comments:
I'm deeply moved by the concern you express here, and I relate to so many of the things you said. The fright of stepping out of the path we think we have to trod. The need to affirm who God made us to be. The use of misery as a shield.
I will say a prayer for your friend Hope.
As a straight woman who felt trapped unto death in a bad marriage, I resonate with your words and join you in prayers for Hope.
Doxy, thank you for this sensitive and heartfelt post. I hope our Hope is reading. You have articulated so well what so many of us, gay and straight, have gone through... the thought that there is no other option, this is what my lot is. Thank God that God breaks in to let us know otherwise.
Pax, C.
This is beautiful.
You are a gift dear Doxy, such a gift to us all.
Praise to God for the gift of you, for the gift of our online community with our heart and mind in God.
I'm so glad you wrote this!
I too have been thinking much about her lately. Very sweet. I too join with you in prayers for Hope.
Blessings
Ruth, Songbird, and Stephanie---welcome to my place, and thanks for your comments and prayers for Hope. I've been visiting all your blogs this morning, and will be back to comment when I can. (Songbird--your sons are gorgeous!)
Fran---I will, and do, praise God for this online community that has offered a lifeline for so many...
But you are far too generous to me, my friend---as I told you privately, I'm an inveterate worrywart! And for some reason, I have not been able to get Hope out of my mind.
When suicide started to seem like the only answer to the trap in which I found myself, God basically told me I was asking the wrong question.
I don't want to come across as encouraging people to break their vows or abandon their commitments---but when the choice seems to be "leave or die," I'm pretty sure the former is the better option...no matter how painful it is in the short-term.
I had certainly married with the intention of honoring "until death do us part," and it was my fear of breaking that commitment (and, of course, fear of the damage to my children) that nearly killed me.
I know I run the risk of being extremely self-serving by making this statement, but it finally hit me that the Doxy who was married to my ex died at the moment she was planning her death and God intervened. I still broke my vows--a fact with which I will have to live for the rest of my life--but it helped me to realize that, without a doubt, the Doxy Before and the Doxy Now are two very different women. There is also no doubt about which one has the better relationship with God.
Which just goes to show you that God is merciful and gracious. Even when we sin and fall short, God can help us rediscover love and meaning in life. I'm living proof of that.
Doxy,I hope your friend reads this. It's a beautiful invitation to a new life. You are a gift to the blog world.
Hope -- I do hope you are reading this. Basic point: you are much loved by God and his/her servants in the blogosphere. Be well.
Doxy, since I'm new to your blog, I think I can say with objectivity, you don't sound self-serving.
Sometimes we are faced with hard choices in life. I think it's clear from context that you aren't talking about easy divorce.
Doxy is one of my Wise Ones in the Blogosphere: next year, IRL, to paraphrase the Jews about Jerusalem.
Thanks, Lindy and Ruth. I appreciate your kind words.
JohnieB---we are going to make that happen, my friend.
Dear Friend and I have a friend who will be headed to General Theological Seminary this fall. We have promised to go up and visit her sometime during the academic year, and I will let the troops know when we do. I'm counting on getting to meet you!
I had certainly married with the intention of honoring "until death do us part," and it was my fear of breaking that commitment (and, of course, fear of the damage to my children) that nearly killed me.
This is where I get stuck in my head every damn time.
Thanks for these words, Doxy.
And when you are up in the Fall, I expect to get in a visit with y'all too!
Eileen---I know I've said it somewhere before, but my rector told me something really helpful when I finally crawled into her office and asked for help.
She told me, "Doxy, a marriage is a covenant between TWO people. It is too heavy to carry all by yourself. He put his end down years ago---you can put yours down now."
I'm sure there are many who would quibble with her theology on this issue, but it was a life-saving, faith-saving, pastoral thing for her to say. I will always be grateful to her for it.
And you can bet you'll be getting an invite! (PJ too---and anyone else in the area I'm forgetting for the moment...)
Sorry I'm late to this post, Doxy, as usual. What a wonderful virtual hug you gave to Hope (interesting pseudonym, if it is one), and what affirming words of wisdom! And thanks for sharing the wise words of your rector.
I remember ending my first marriage. It was such a freeing thing to do, once I made the decision. It was HELL making it though, for all of the reasons cited above. It was so necessary. I could not be me in that marriage, yet I remembering thinking what was so wrong with me that God wanted me to be trapped in an awful marriage and thinking about killing myself (and I did try, twice). I knew I had to leave when he said, "Too bad you didn't succeed." He was equally miserable, yet we both had this thought that we would go to hell if we divorced. Horrible.
And hugs to Hope if she is reading. Please give heed to the words you read here.
Doxy, I so resonate with your comment above. Laying down my half of that marriage was the hardest work I ever did, and it took a long time to recover from it. Bless you for your thoughtful honesty.
I knew I had to leave when he said, "Too bad you didn't succeed."
That is just evil...
I recently went for a check-in visit with my psychiatrist, and I was telling her about the Hydra's (see my post below) e-mail that basically said the same thing your ex-husband said.
Before she could stop herself, she burst out with "What an asshole!" She was then abjectly apologetic about what she termed her breach of professionalism, but I loved her for it... ;-)
The more I ponder this, the more I believe that marriage should make you more of who you really are. Being in relationship is always going to be hard, because it requires you to think of someone other than yourself---but if you are BOTH thinking of the other, then each of you should be having your needs met.
I believe that, at heart, I am a loving, loyal, passionate person. My ex simply didn't want or value what I had to offer, so slowly I buried everything that most defined me.
But some things simply will not (and should not) stay buried...
I am so grateful to be free to be me again...and I guess that's why Hope's story resonated so deeply with me. There is no one in her life who really knows who she is, and that is such a sad and lonely place to be.
It is a great burden to have to live someone else's life---because it will NEVER fit you, and it will always rub sores on your soul.
Ah -- the damn divorce thing. As I posted in the Lamott item just one down, I did not give my first marriage what it deserved. It is clear to me that if I had it would not have "saved" the marriage but perhaps I would have done more "growing up" at the time if I had been more directly attentive. Perhaps my ex would have also grown. We now stay mildly in touch and I am very blessed by the subsequent growth that God has provided. I think that if one really pays attention to ones marriage it will be clear whether it should continue or not. I worry about the young who treat marriage as disposable as kleenex. It seems likely (but not guaranteed) that GLBT people who are given the chance to marry will, at least at first, take it more seriously than many straight people do. As far as I can tell, everyone on this blog takes marriage (both failed and successful) very seriously indeed. And that is a good thing.
And I LOVE Emily Dickinson.
Doxy,
Thank you for the gift that you gave me in that post. I am still crying. Sometimes we just need to know we are significant on some level somewhere. You will never know what it meant to me to find that post. Although I was in the blogger world for a very short period of time, I came to have a genuine feeling of love and concern for many of you with whom I was privileged enough to correspond. You are all in my thoughts and prayers. I've kept up with everyone's blogs and rejoice with them in happiness and pray for them in sadness. I still find comfort here. And you gave me a much needed hug today. It is nothing short of God's work when you are scraping the absolute bottom and a hand reaches out to you in the simplest of ways and gives you a sense of peace and joy. Thank you, Doxy. You are a blessing.
Hope
I am just so relieved to know you are there! Thanks so much for stopping by.
God bless you, my friend. You will remain in my prayers.
Love,
Doxy
Oh Doxy. I am so glad Hope read your words.
Hope is the thing with feathers...
after all.
I am not your Hope. I’m a bit older, but share her story, am employed in an area of ministry of my church, and have been reading these blogs and crying. I try to remember that God is in everything, even questions, (Why do I feel this way? Is this real? Where are you, God?) As my faith has matured, God has become infinitely bigger and does not fit in the small box I grew up believing in. I believe that God calls us to live with authenticity, integrity, and gratitude for the gift of this life. It occurs to me that my newly opened mind might have to extend to self acceptance too, and maybe the way I feel is just the way I feel and not wrong or evil or unforgiving or selfish or controlling or any of the things my husband says when I can’t respond as he needs. I know that peace does not depend on outward circumstances, but my prayers do not seem to make one bit of difference, even in my own spirit and certainly not in my circumstances. I have even prayed to love him again, even though that sounds like a very real death of my spirit. It seems that searching only causes more chaos, and there is no way back. I can’t think of any way out, any solution, any way to hold on where I am. I, too, often think that death would be preferable to this pain and probably easier for my family to deal with than knowing what is inside me, but that is not a step I will take. I wonder how many people are like me, this very moment, blind with tears, trying to put into words the longing for peace and answers that your writing stirs. How many turn to the faceless glare of a computer screen to find someone who understands? Doxy, Cecilia, Songbird, and all whose kindness and empathy have touched me, thank you for the comfort your words give. Perhaps God is using your stories to answer my prayers… Knowing that you are there, somewhere, and that you can see a light even though I cannot, makes a difference.
Lost
I believe that Jesus meant it when he said "I am come that you might have life, and have it more abundantly."
I'll have to keep this in mind myself.
Hi Hope!!! :)
Doxy, when I meet you in real life, I'm gonna start crying. (Fair warning, pal.)
I'm just trying to imagine how difficult it must be to acknowledge something within yourself that you know will be the cause of much upheaval in your life.
Divorce was that way for me. Many of you have already expressed, more eloquently than I can, how difficult it was to break out of the cocoon in which you lived. I could not conceive of suicide, but I did think that death would be a preferable alternative to the pain I was going through.
I love this:
She told me, "Doxy, a marriage is a covenant between TWO people. It is too heavy to carry all by yourself. He put his end down years ago---you can put yours down now."
Thanks for sharing that.
Dear Hope and dear Lost,
Remember those words about abundance and remember that there are many of us out here doing our best (though imperfectly of course) to embody the welcoming love of Godde. I pray that you will have life in abundance in this life, and that the Holy Spirit will lead you not to demean your beautiful precious selves but to open them to the endless, endless compassion of Jesus and the friends of Jesus.
Thank you, Doxy, for initiating and hosting this conversation. And thanks be to Godde!
Hope and Lost, both of you, I'm praying for you.
I'm very late to this whole discussion, but I am quite moved by it. Hope and Lost, you are in my prayers. Doxy, I've said this before: you don't write often, but when you do write, your words are filled with beauty, wisdom, and grace.
Wherever you are right now, love, I wish you many blessings.
Hi Doxy...
I hope this finds you safely home and happy from your world travels.
Just wanted to let you know that I have found what I believe to be and hope to be an open and accepting church with a pastor who embraces all people. She has agreed to meet with me and try to help me find healing. This will be the first time I have ever openly confessed my heart's burden to anyone face to face and my blogger community is the only place I know to go and ask for prayer as I begin this process. Thank you for your words of wisdom and guidance which have helped to get me this far.
Hope
Hope---nothing could have made my homecoming sweeter than this. God bless you, my friend! I hope your minister gives you the help you need to be happy and whole.
Love,
Doxy
Oops; hit the wrong key! Thanks for the link, Doxy, and welcome home!
And thanks to you, Hope, for taking the support offered you here to go and discover what I pray will be a place and people who will nourish you in this work, and for letting us know the news. It's truly wonderful, and gives my spirits a much appreciated lift.
My prayers join the others for your continued blessing.
May the grace and peace of Godde be always with us all.
Oh how very wonderful, Hope is back! What a blessing.
Hope, Doxy....you ladies are incredible!
Blessings!
Post a Comment